• GALLERY
  • WORK
    • Wine
    • Alc
    • F&B
    • Experiences
  • BRANDS
    • CASE STUDIES
    • Dillon's
    • Mason
  • ABOUT
    • Insite
    • Scope
  • Info
    • Working with us
    • FAQ
    • Docs
  • Words
  • Contact

INSITE

Strategy, brand creation & design.

  • GALLERY
  • WORK
    • Wine
    • Alc
    • F&B
    • Experiences
  • BRANDS
    • CASE STUDIES
    • Dillon's
    • Mason
  • ABOUT
    • Insite
    • Scope
  • Info
    • Working with us
    • FAQ
    • Docs
  • Words
  • Contact

Brand risk — AI is a brand value statement

Dear brands — here are some facts followed by questions and then straight advice.

But first, understand that this isn’t an anti-AI rant. This article is an anti-blindly-adopt a tool or process without considering the impact on your brand rant.

Facts:

Recent consumer research on the use of AI in marketing visuals and advertisements showed that:

1. — 50% of consumers can discern AI generated visuals from human creative.

2. — 55% of consumers view brands that use AI in their marketing and advertising negatively, with feelings of scepticism and distrust, believing these brands to be inauthentic and untrustworthy. Sentiments become even more negative when the visuals use AI people and this result becomes even stronger in emotional product offering categories like lifestyle, premium food & bev, travel & hospitality.

3. — As a result, AI generated content performs substantially lower in sales with an even higher decline in brand equity over a longer period.

Ok so those are the facts.

The questions are:

A. If you as a brand owner or manager was told that a particular communication spend would be guaranteed to underperform by a statistically specific amount, would you be able to calculate the loss in dollars compared to that of your benchmark outcomes?

B. If you could choose to avoid producing communication that would perform poorly and damage your brand, wouldn’t you?

C. Finally, if you were faced with a decision to take on this kind of financial loss, communication failure and brand damage, would you not make it a priority to have this discussion with your management and communication teams to gather a clear consensus? So as to make sure moving forward that each step was with open eyes?

Though these questions might feel rhetorical, the reality is that many of you might actually be participating in AI within your outgoing comms without acknowledging the risk of AI to your brand and business. Further, most of you have never tabled the discussion with the team let alone defined communication strategy and policy.

So what we’re seeing is that because of the lack of decisions, policy and policing, brands are allowing their comms teams to use AI without their knowledge. Or in cases where it’s presented as an option, the decision to accept the AI content is made without weight or guidance. And without comparative benchmarks.

The Advice:

The brands we’ve had the opportunity to work and grow with — to sweat, cry and celebrate with — have invested an intense amount of money and effort to get the brand to the level of success they’re at.

So to see this work invested in consumer equity and loyal culture be seriously and possibly permanently undermined by a matter-of-fact approach to a lower quality form of execution feels wasteful and kind of nutty.

This is why we are guiding our clients to avoid AI in their visual communication — at least at this stage until it grows up and proves to be superior.

In the interim we suggest to define a strategic policy that gets distributed to all teams, providing everyone with clear goals, philosophy and legal and moral guardrails for the time being. This will help you to avoid the kind of situations we’ve seen such as where subcontracted content creators are deciding for themselves to use AI which could directly negatively impact your brand.

In addition, we recommend to calendar an ongoing series of check-ins with the above research to continue to inform the viewpoints and guide future decisions.

Cheers

Monday 11.16.26
Posted by leslie akse
Newer / Older

All content & images copyright Insite Design or Credited Owners. 2025.